Why Direct Mail Is Still the Most Trusted Marketing Channel in 2025

In a time when misinformation is everywhere and consumer skepticism is at an all-time high, trust has become marketing’s most valuable currency. And for all the new tools and platforms marketers have adopted in the digital age, one channel consistently earns that trust more than any other: direct mail.

Despite years of predictions about its decline, direct mail has not only survived — it’s thriving. In fact, it’s become the quiet powerhouse in omnichannel marketing strategies. As digital fatigue, privacy concerns, and ad fraud undermine confidence in online media, marketers and consumers alike are rediscovering the value of physical mail.

Why Trust in Digital Is Eroding

The stats tell the story. Americans are seeing more ads than ever, but believing fewer of them. Social media feeds are crowded with questionable claims, sponsored content is often indistinguishable from organic posts, and AI-generated misinformation is rampant. Inboxes are overrun with scams, phishing attempts, and generic automated messaging.

It’s no surprise that trust in digital advertising is plummeting. According to Vericast’s 2024 report, only 38% of consumers say they trust digital ads, and nearly 60% express concern about data privacy. The result? Consumers scroll past ads or actively avoid them — and marketers are left with diminishing returns.

Direct Mail: The Channel That Still Delivers Credibility

Contrast that with what happens at the mailbox. Direct mail benefits from a legacy of trust built over generations. It’s the channel people associate with important, official communications — from banks, healthcare providers, insurers, and government agencies. That context lends credibility to every piece of mail, even promotional ones.

But it’s not just perception. Direct mail is governed by real accountability. Bulk mailings require permits tied to verified businesses. Data vendors are held to higher standards. Physical mail is harder to spoof, and fraud is rare.

It’s also a sensory medium. Research from Temple University shows that physical media activates more emotional processing in the brain, leading to greater recall and brand favorability compared to digital.

Direct Mail Trusted and Actionable

Click to enlarge.

Proven Performance with Consumers

Consumers aren’t just noticing mail — they’re acting on it.

• 60% say they’ve made a purchase after receiving a direct mail piece

• 52% say receiving mail makes a brand feel more important than an email

• Only 23% say they feel overwhelmed by mail, compared to 46% for email

Even among Millennials and Gen Z, the myth that “younger people don’t like mail” doesn’t hold up. 90% of Millennials say mail is reliable, and 57% have responded to a mail offer in the past year.

And trust doesn’t just drive initial engagement — it impacts long-term value. Across industries, brands consistently find that customers acquired via direct mail have higher average order values and lifetime value than digital responders.

The Takeaway for Print & Mail Providers

This is more than validation — it’s a clear signal of where opportunity lies. As marketers seek performance they can trust, direct mail isn’t just “traditional,” it's essential.

Consider the accountability, reliability, and ROI of mail — and integrate it more deeply into broader channel strategies to reach audiences tired of being tracked, tricked, or tuned out online.

Because when trust matters most, mail still delivers.

The preceding content was provided by a contributor unaffiliated with Printing Impressions. The views expressed within may not directly reflect the thoughts or opinions of the staff of Printing Impressions.